This Content Is Only For Subscribers
If you’re in the heart of Manhattan and craving authentic Italian food—whether it’s family-style feasts, refined regional cuisine, or pasta-centric tasting menus—Times Square delivers. Here’s a magazine-style guide spotlighting standout Italian spots that satisfy both taste and ambiance.
1. Carmine’s – The Family-Style Favorite
Nestled on 44th Street, Carmine’s is a Theater District institution beloved for its gargantuan portions and warm, communal vibe. Expect platters of made-to-order pasta, rich seafood, and house-made desserts—all served in a cozy dining room reminiscent of an Italian-American wedding feast. Its popularity is no secret, with labels like “exceptional” and “truly amazing” frequently popping up in reviews. “It’s a good place to bring a big group of out-of-towners… perfectly fine”—a testament to its hearty, welcoming appeal.
2. Tony’s Di Napoli – Southern Neapolitan Charm
Just steps away, Tony’s Di Napoli offers classic Southern Italian dishes in a vibrant, convivial atmosphere. Reviewers rave about the “best calamari ever” and outstanding mussels crafted with authentic Neapolitan flair. It’s perfect for lively dinners and seafood lovers seeking a warm, bustling setting.
3. Becco – Pasta Tasting with an Elegant Flair
On nearby Restaurant Row, Becco is a standout run by Lidia Bastianich and her son. Famed for its $29.95 pasta tasting menu and a thoughtfully curated $35 Italian wine list, this spot is ideal for tasting-driven diners. Whether you’re indulging in Osso Bucco or sipping acclaimed vintages, Becco delivers refined flavors with consistent charm.
4. Barbetta – A Historic Gem
Tucked away since 1906 on West 46th Street, Barbetta is the oldest family-owned Italian restaurant in the Theater District. Specializing in Piedmontese cuisine, it was a pioneer in showcasing seasonal delicacies like white truffles, and it continues to shine as a piece of culinary history with a Zagat-approved reputation.
5. All’Antico Vinaio – Italian Sandwich Craftsmanship
For a lighter, yet equally authentic option, the Midtown West outpost of All’Antico Vinaio brings Tuscan flavors to handheld form. Famous for its overstuffed schiacciata sandwiches—like the La Paradiso (pistachio, mortadella, stracciatella) and La Favolosa (salami, eggplant, artichoke cream)—this spot marries Italian tradition with grab-and-go modernity.The New Yorker
At-a-Glance Comparison
| Restaurant | : What Makes It Special |
|---|---|
| Carmine’s | Family-style, generous portions, perfect for groups |
| Tony’s Di Napoli | Southern Italian seafood, warm and inviting |
| Becco | Pasta tasting menu, elegant and wine-forward |
| Barbetta | Historic, Piedmont cuisine, classic ambiance |
| All’Antico Vinaio | Iconic Tuscan sandwiches—quick, artisanal, casual |
Why It Matters
Times Square isn’t just Broadway and billboards—it’s a launching pad into diverse Italian experiences. Whether you’re splitting a family-style feast, exploring refined regional dishes, or grabbing a gourmet bite between shows, these restaurants bring authenticity and variety in one of the world’s busiest blocks.
